top of page

Flaccid vs. Semi-erect Pumping: Which is Best for Penis Enlargement?

Penis pumping is a popular method for men seeking to enlarge their penis. A common question among users is whether to pump with a flaccid or erect penis. However, we believe the discussion should be centered around flaccid vs. semi-erect pumping, not erect. Therefore, this article will explore the differences between flaccid and semi-erect pumping and explain why semi-erect pumping, precisely at 80% erection, is the recommended approach for effective and safe penis enlargement.

Flaccid Pumping: Ideal for ED Issues and Blood Flow

  • Flaccid pumping is primarily used by men with erectile dysfunction (ED) or those looking to maintain blood flow and expansion.

  • Entering the pump flaccid can lead to uneven expansion and a less uniform appearance.

  • It may also result in a "pumper's donut," an accumulation of fluid below the glans. For more information on the donut effect, refer to our previous article on the topic.

Semi-Erect Pumping: Maximizing Growth, Uniformity, and Safety

  • Pumping with a semi-erect penis (80% erection) can lead to faster cylinder packing, resulting in quicker expansion and growth.

  • Entering the cylinder semi-erect allows the penis to adjust and expand uniformly, preventing uneven expansion and pumper's donut.

  • Semi-erect pumping results in a more aesthetically pleasing, uniform penis post-session.

  • This method also reduces the risk of injury compared to fully erect pumping, as it allows for better pressure control and adaptation within the cylinder.

Cons of Pumping with an Erection

  • The primary downside of pumping with an erection is the potential for injury due to improper preparation or extreme pressure.

  • Common pumping injuries include bruising, loss of circulation, discolouration, tingling, loss of sensation, blisters, and popped blood vessels.

  • To avoid injury, make sure to warm up, lubricate, and use appropriate pressure levels during your pumping sessions.

Our Experience and Recommendations

  • Upon analyzing the feedback and results from a wide range of our clients, it has become evident that initiating the pump at a semi-erect state (80% erection) offers an ideal blend of growth, aesthetic improvement, and safety.

  • Semi-erect pumping allows for better inner chamber expansion, resulting in more girth gains and even pressure distribution.

  • Flaccid pumping may be more effective for length gains, but other methods like penis hanging, ADS use, penis extenders, and manual exercises can also be employed for length development, with greater results.


After considering the differences between flaccid and semi-erect pumping, we highly recommend semi-erect pumping, specifically at 80% erection, for effective and safe penis enlargement. This method offers a better balance of gains, uniformity, and safety compared to flaccid or fully erect pumping. Always prioritize safety and proper technique when engaging in penis pumping, and remember that it's a process, not a marathon. Enjoy the journey towards achieving your desired results.


bottom of page